Along with millions of Americans, I watched the Vice Presidential Debate last night. The first question that came to mind was “Who is this Moderator?” Her name is Martha Raddatz, and I wish I had learned more about her before the debate.
Joe Biden and Paul Ryan each accomplished their goals. Each got to recite their memorized responses to questions, whether their answers were responsive or not. Paul Ryan clearly had a mission to establish that although young, he was well informed about foreign policy matters. Biden clearly had his own mission. Doing damage control after the President’s lack-luster debate performance, Biden was charged with the mission of confronting Ryan whenever he told lies, or made misleading statements. Biden did interrupt many times to contest the truthfulness of something Paul was saying. Although Biden was perceived by some as too aggressive, he accomplished the goal of creating questions about the truthfulness of Ryan. Ryan accomplished his goal of convincing the audience that he was ready to take control if Romney should be elected, and then at some time be unable to serve.
Of course the minute the debate was over, journalists and reporters were quick to answer the question, “Who won the debate?” Some reported that Biden won. Some reported that Ryan won.Some reported that the outcome was a tie. In their haste to get the story out, each of these media sources failed to identify the real winner. The real winner was Martha Raddatz, the moderator.
Raddatz was knowledgeable and professional. She was direct and in control. She was not condescending but clearly an equal to the men she was moderating. She was in control of the debate and was unafraid to interrupt when necessary. Her appearance was appropriate for the occasion. She did not mention her children or family when she was introduced. She made no attempt to become the focus of the debate or to use this moment to attract attention to herself. The contrast between Martha and Jim Lehrer, the 78 year old anchor of the previous presidential debate was dramatic.
Raddatz was praised for her “calm-yet-firm” moderating style. She was able to “control the conversation between the two talkative candidates while letting them have brief dialogues.”
The outstanding performance of Raddatz was recognized by film critic Roger Ebert as he wrote “she makes a strong impression. Knows her stuff.” CNN reporter Roland Martin said “’Martha Raddatz is not messing around. You hear that Jim Lehrer? She ain’t allowing filibustering!’
Martha Raddatz was an outstanding choice for moderator of this debate. She is a veteran ABC News correspondent. Her list of international assignments and reporting achievements makes some “secretaries of state seem like work-shy stay-at-homes.” She has reported from Mosul and Sadr City during her 21 trips to Iraq. She began working for WCVB in Boston, before becoming NPR’s Pentagon correspondent in 1993. In 1999 she shifted to ABC News as state department correspondent and then became senior national security correspondent in 2003, a post that required extensive reporting from war-torn Iraq.
The posting in Baghdad led Raddatz to write a book, The Long Road Home, a detailed account of a platoon of American soldiers trapped and besieged by Shia militia in Sadr City, in a two-day battle that saw eight US soldiers killed.Raddatz became ABC’s White House correspondent during the second term of the Bush administration. By the end of 2008 she was named to the prestigious role of senior foreign affairs correspondent.
Raddatz is only the sixth woman to moderate or co-moderate a presidential or vice-presidential debate.
Given Martha Raddatz credentials, and stellar performance in the debate, women across the country are energized this morning because a woman was recognized around the country for her intelligence, professionalism, and competence. Predictably Sarah Palin had only criticism for this accomplished, professional performance. Palin said:
“ …the moderator allowed one candidate to absolutely run roughshod over the conversation, over the opponent,”
“That’s a tough format. It reminded me…of watching a musk ox run across the tundra with somebody underfoot. In this case, when it came to style, Paul Ryan was underfoot because of the moderator allowing Biden to do interrupting, to kind of take control of the conversation.”
For four years we have watched as Sarah Palin has damaged the image of professional women. Today we have a perfect example of an accomplished professional woman who made women proud, and an example of another who embarrasses us on a regular basis. Martha Raddatz made us proud. Palin is an embarrassment to women, to her country, to her party, and even to her family.








47 comments
Comments feed for this article
October 12, 2012 at 10:20 am
Jim In Texas
It is SO unfair to insist on actual answers, dontcha know?
October 12, 2012 at 11:46 am
malialitman
Jim,
They don’t even require that the answers be truthful, but just answers.
October 12, 2012 at 10:26 am
eclecticsandra
I have seen her reports on ABC, and have always felt she was doing an outstanding job. Never even considered how her gender could have made a difference. She did an excellent job of moderating.
October 12, 2012 at 11:44 am
malialitman
eclecticsandra,
Exactly! Her gender was never paRt of the dialogue! That’s exactly why she was so impressive.
October 12, 2012 at 10:31 am
Sarah Halftime
Mamma bears will eat their young and more often, male bears will kill and eat them.
Musk ox rarely run with someone (a human) underfoot. If they do run with something underfoot, it is typically their young.
Since the days of Chuckey and Sally working at the wasilla high school, it has been known that the Quitter is a sore loser. If she didn’t win, she complained to mommy and daddy. Who inturn would do anything to shut up her temper tantrum. At the cost of other students.
The Quitter is a sore loser.
And we all know she don’t like accomplishments that include positive work ethics and/or brainy stuff. I’m not surprised she slammed Ms Raddatz. It is how the Quitter rolls.
October 12, 2012 at 11:43 am
malialitman
Sarah Halftime,
I wish she’d roll out of America.
October 12, 2012 at 10:32 am
Deni
Esquire said it best: “The difference between Paul Ryan and Sarah Palin? Lipstick.”
October 12, 2012 at 11:42 am
malialitman
Deni,
Great commentary!
October 12, 2012 at 1:07 pm
Donal
I’d like to add another… literacy.
October 12, 2012 at 3:20 pm
malialitman
Donal,
Yes, that would be a welcome addition.
October 12, 2012 at 4:50 pm
jk
Barely, in the case of Ryan, although he surely have fooled quite a few people.
October 12, 2012 at 10:46 am
mistah charley, ph.d.
I liked Charlie Pierce’s summing up of the debate at the Esquire politics blog: “You know what’s the difference between Paul Ryan and Sarah Palin? Lipstick.”
October 12, 2012 at 11:41 am
malialitman
mistah charley, ph.d.
Thank you for that ! I hadn’t seen that.
October 12, 2012 at 10:51 am
Cracklin' Charlie
I thought Martha did a fantastic job! She is absolutely more qualified than Sarah Palin to moderate this debate. What a ridiculous statement from the unqualified, overcompensated mistake from Alaska. Someone please give her a big pile of money, so she will just go away, and leave governance to those who actually understand the very real challenges faced by American citizens.
She and both candidates from the Republican ticket this year, are some of the most superficial, unintelligent, scornful people that I’ve ever watched run for office. They have told us time and again about their disdain for the wealth-challenged, and how disastrous the policies they advocate would be for our country. But Sarah gets to go on the teevee, and pontificate about who smiled more, or who interrupted more.
This is ridiculous! It’s not about their smile, it’s about their obvious lack of compassion, if not actual malevolence, for 47% of the population! A Romney/Ryan administration would be very bad news for the United States.
October 12, 2012 at 11:40 am
malialitman
Cracklin Charlie,
The funny thing is that I was in the process of writing this post before I even knew Palin had been critical of Martha. It seems inevitable that if there is an accomplished woman, Palin will disparage her. I don’t know the party to which Martha belongs, but I’m sure it’s not Sarah Palin’s.
October 12, 2012 at 11:12 am
Gene
Sarah Palin is an embarrassment to all women. She is a FAILURE and will do anything to stay in the Press. Her ‘BOTS’ are Delusional and are TROLLING any Sites that criticize anything Palin. Not one of the Palins nor their ‘BOTS’ have the CAJONES to respond to Todd Palin’s Sex Trafficking
and Prostitution Ring Allegations, because they know that the Allegations are the TRUTH. Drugs have taken over the lives of the Palin Family and it shows. Bristol Palin has no Dancing Ability and ALL OF AMERICA knows it.
She should never have been allowed on DWTS.
October 12, 2012 at 11:38 am
malialitman
Gene,
Homeland Security is still considering my
FOIA request, so there is still hope that the statement of David Cheney might confirm what Shailey Tripp has reported.
October 12, 2012 at 11:27 am
nswfm
Palin is a useless dolt. Appologies to useless dolts everywhere.
October 12, 2012 at 11:29 am
Millie
As usual – Palin has no clue! She is an absolute disgrace to America, Alaska (specifically), the Republican party and to women (as you already said, Malia).
The media and everyone else have to STOP giving her coverage as it only keeps her ‘in view’ which is what she wants. She doesn’t give a damn whether she receives positive or negative coveragae.
She is one evil and ugly woman, inside and out!
October 12, 2012 at 11:36 am
malialitman
Millie,
The irony is that she portrays herself as a woman’s advocate, and she does more damage than any man.
October 12, 2012 at 11:47 am
laprofesora
Did she really say,”…allowing Biden to do interrupting”? My god, the woman can’t even speak the English language, how can she dare criticize someone as accomplished as Martha Raddatz? Please make her go away…
October 12, 2012 at 12:50 pm
malialitman
laprofesora,
She criticizes others while she uses words like misunderestimate, refudiate, weee-weed- up, etc.
October 12, 2012 at 12:00 pm
avahome
When you are sitting at a table, looking straight at someone questioning you, you get a bead for their sincerity. Martha most certainly gave a no nonsense aura. Lordy, I could even understand every word Martha said so the questions were clear, concise and probing.
Sarah Palin clearly does not know the difference between “wanting and having”….same thing GW Bush had. So once you get what you want, what do you do next?
Lastly Malia, did you see this: http://news.yahoo.com/judge-wont-block-names-maine-prostitution-case-132851008.html
Gonna be a real barn burner once the John’s names are made public. Hope Shailey is paying attention.
October 12, 2012 at 12:48 pm
malialitman
avahome,
You betcha I’m paying attention!
October 12, 2012 at 12:12 pm
gsb
Malia:
have to disagree with you that Palin is a disgrace to her family. Not so.. they all think she is just wonderful, intelligent.and perfect. Bristol, is following her example to the” T”
October 12, 2012 at 12:48 pm
malialitman
gsb,
Of course you may be right, but I hope they are just taking advantage of the fame and fortune, and after her popularity is gone, we may hear about the real feelings of her children.
October 12, 2012 at 12:16 pm
elj
Another excellent post Malia… extremely well stated all around.
October 12, 2012 at 12:46 pm
malialitman
elj,
Thank you for your support and encouragement!
October 12, 2012 at 12:23 pm
Beaglemom
I liked the format. Sitting around a table (sort of) is much better than standing behind a podium. It has to be more relaxing for the participants unless, of course, one of them has cheat sheets to cover up with a handkerchief.
In my admittedly biased opinion, Vice President Biden romped all over Paul Ryan during their debate. Keep in mind that early last summer, when Biden made speeches about the GOP conspiracy against improving the economy, he was accused of being senile, too prone to “gaffes,” etc. Well, all of that is now distant history. Not only has Joe Biden been an extraordinarily gifted vice president, he proved himself again to be a forceful debater. All of those years in the House and Senate were great preparation for him.
October 12, 2012 at 12:45 pm
malialitman
Beaglemom,
I thought he did an outstanding job too! He comes across much more genuine, and with Biden you know that we get what we see.
October 12, 2012 at 1:12 pm
abbafan
Hello Malia! Yes, I happened to watch the VP debate last night. My wife, who is not as passionate about politics as I am, turned to me and asked “who is that lady? We were both very impressed with Ms. Raddatz. She was very informed, professional, concise, and in control; a no-nonsense moderator with gravitas! Her credentials are impeccable and outstanding, unlike the jealous simpleton stank skank who reared her ugly head and inserted her useless two cents. Yeah $arah, that is how REAL , INFORMED, EDUCATED journalists present themselves. LEARN from her example, you stupid idiot!
October 12, 2012 at 3:20 pm
malialitman
abbafan,
I’m glad to know that you had the same reaction! I thought she was outstanding
October 12, 2012 at 1:15 pm
Eric
It was SO frustrating to hear Ryan EVADE answering directly even the simplest of Martha’s questions, but instead he would do the GOP “bob and weave” each time. I wish she had been given a button controlling an electrode connected strategically to Ryan, so she could “taser” him whenever he strayed from directly answering… Or maybe the table should have been smaller, so she could just give him a swift kick in the shin [or elsewhere]!
October 12, 2012 at 1:22 pm
Jason3
Couldn’t we unstatehood Alaska until palin (s) go anywhere, somewhere…elsewhere…
October 12, 2012 at 1:28 pm
Alaska Cod Piece
Yes, the half term half wit’s face is all over the place thanks to her ‘pundintry’ at FOX. It is SO gratifying to see that the comments wherever $creech’s spew is reposted run 100-1 against the quitter – HuffPo, Politico Mediaite, Buzzfeed, Yahoo/Google News, even Fox, to name but a few. Of course, $he is so delusional she thinks her ‘insights’ matter, never realizing that $he is the proverbial trainwreck that people can’t help watch to hear/see what hateful blatherings will appear, shaking their heads in amazement at her idiocy all the while.
October 12, 2012 at 4:53 pm
jk
Palin cried “sexism,” yet didn’t care one bit when it worked to her advantage (like when Biden couldn’t bring the hammer down on her idiocy).
And now people are actually asking for her commentary because she debated Biden before? That wasn’t a debate, Sarah. You would have known it was a debate because Joe would have flattened you and you would have been reduced to a whimpering pile of lipstick.
October 12, 2012 at 11:12 pm
DobieTracker
i USED to really like and respect Gwen Ifil.
I still like her. NO respect after she let Palin disrespect HER and refuse to answer a question.
Raddatz I really like and respect.
I cannot picture Raddatz ever allowing ANYONE to walk over her, not Romney, not Biden, not Obama.
Raddatz would have called Missy Palin on her ” spin it” move just as she called Lyin’ Ryan last night on the specifics of his tax plan which he NEVER did give. When he tried to fill in with word salad, Raddatz called Lyin’ Ryan on and moved on.
Palin would pee her pants if she ever met Raddatz in a dark alley even if she had all her family with her.
NOW, IF the next moderator will control the next debate and do their job Obama will have a better chance of prevailing BUT HE STILL BETTER REALIZE HE IS IN A STREET FIGHT, BARE KNUCKLES AND NO RULES !
President Obama needs to get over being so cautious. I know he does not want to project the image of “the angry black man” but he has every right in the world to get angry when Romney lies like a rug to his face and calling Romney on his lies makes him an angry man who happens to be black ( and also 50% white) and Obama has a much right to express his anger when confronting lies as does (100%) white Biden.
Let the extreme right call him what they will but he (we) cannot afford for President Obama to be cowed by what others may call him. Let them call him an “angry black man”—-no big deal as President Obama’s past, present and future demeanor as a calm, cool, collected decision maker is solid enough to withstand that kind of strategy.
Besides, it will be 1) hard to “name call” Obama as angry after his way too polite demeanor in the first debate and 2) previous criticism of President Obama’s reputation for being “unemotional” and “too composed” will counter any “angry black man” comments.
Obama was criticized for looking dour and not smiling.
Biden is now criticized for smiling and laughing.
I think it is clear that no matter what attitude is expressed, they will be criticized.
IF YOU’RE WALKING ON THIN ICE, YOU MIGHT AS WELL DANCE
October 13, 2012 at 8:30 am
malialitman
Dobie Tracker,
I think it will be Candee Crowly who will moderate on Tues., and I don’t know if she’ll control the debaters as much as we would like. However anything will be an improvement over Jim Lehrer.
October 13, 2012 at 10:06 am
carolnc
Here’s a link you might find interesting. Too bad this wasn’t there when Todd was visiting Shailey!
http://www.wral.com/prostitute-patrons-can-t-hide-their-faces-anymore/11656687/
October 13, 2012 at 2:02 pm
malialitman
carolnc,
Yes I think that as women become more and more powerful in our political world they are demanding that if women are to be prosecuted for prostitution than their johns and pimps must be prosecuted as well. It’s either legal for all, or illegal for all, and Todd may be an example of that. We’ll see what homeland security says in response to the FOIA request!
October 13, 2012 at 2:41 pm
YoPalinSux
Dear God,
Are there really people who think that Paul. RYAN!! is READY to serve as the Commander – in – CHIEF of the United States of America????
I wouldn’t trust that lying sack of Sh…Stuff (; winks to SP) to water my plants.
Holy krist.
October 13, 2012 at 2:45 pm
malialitman
YoPalin Sux,
Given the people who supported McCain and Palin, it isn’t too surprising that people think Ryan is ready.
October 13, 2012 at 4:18 pm
aj weishar
The Palin musk ox statement is hilarious. Reword it to say bulimic, musty ox trampling people and it sounds like someone who has been annoying us for the past five years.
Martha Raddatz did a much better job of stifling Paul Ryan’s illegal Gish Gallop technique. It’s the same one Romney used, multiple random statements in the response. Biden was on it immediately, rolling his eyes and properly challenging the BS. If you dissect Ryan’s answers to the questions, you will find few direct answers and multiple unrelated statements. Gallop is a great term for reeling off as many statements as you can, racing the moderator and your opponent.
October 14, 2012 at 9:02 am
malialitman
aj,
It’s like a free commercial instead of a debate.
October 14, 2012 at 10:35 am
Anne
I didn’t know who Martha Raddatz was before the debate, but she proved herself to be a highly effective moderator who didn’t hesitate to ask questions of either man. She is such a marked contrast to Jim Lehrer, who lost control of the debate early on and allowed Willard to lie at least 27 times during that debate. It’s a sad commentary when a serial liar like him is said to have “won” his debate, and even sadder that the polls shifted in his favor after such a flagrantly dishonest performance to convince non-wealthy voters that he really cares about him. In a heartening contrast, VP Biden didn’t allow Lyin’ Ryan to get away with HIS lies. I loved the way he brought up Ryan’s begging for funds from the very stimulus he and other Republicans have been publicly criticizing. I also loved the way he exposed the dangerous fallacies of the Romney-Ryan policies on women’s reproductive rights and Medicare. I sincerely hope that the presidential debate on Tuesday will be a continuation of mercilessly pouncing on Republican lies and distortions. As for Ms. Raddatz, she is a striking contradiction to the simple-minded, emotionally stunted adolescent in a 48-year-old body that Sarah Palin is.
October 14, 2012 at 12:11 pm
malialitman
Anne,
I was actually in the process of writing my comments about what a great job Martha had done during the debate when I came across Palin’s criticism. It seems that no matter what issue if there is any opportunity to promote women, Palin does the opposite.
October 14, 2012 at 11:55 am
Anne
I meant “…convince non-wealthy voters that he really cares about them.”